COMPARISON OF MY BEST JEWELRY SAFES
| PRODUCT | PROS | CONS | PRICE |
|---|---|---|---|
Amazon Basics |
– Affordable Price – Adequate Storage Space – Easy-to-Use Keypad – Sturdy Build – Dual Locking Mechanisms |
– Thin Walls and Lightweight Construction – Lack of Fireproofing and Waterproofing – Faulty Keypad and Key Mechanisms – Inadequate Mounting Design – Moisture Vulnerability – Limited Customer Support |
Check Price Amazon.com |
KAPUCI |
– Multiple Access Options – Sleek and Modern Design – Internal Padding and Shelf – Auto-Open and Auto-Close – Spacious Interior – Easy Setup and Installation |
– Poor Fingerprint Lock Recognition – Build Quality Issues – Stability Concerns – Limited Security – Inadequate Customer Support – Price vs. Value |
Check Price Amazon.com |
Paragon |
– Affordable Price – Ease of Installation – Provides Basic Security – Hidden Installation Option – Sturdy Construction |
– Poor Packaging and Assembly – Subpar Quality – Limited Interior Space – Lack of Instructions and Support – Unreliable Performance – Not Suitable for High-Security Needs |
Check Price Amazon.com |
Elder Welder |
– Inconspicuous Design – Easy Installation – Robust Construction – Secure Lock Mechanism – Customizable Cover Plate – Excellent Customer Service |
– Shallow Depth – Limited Storage Capacity – Installation Compatibility Concerns – Potentially Weak Mounting – Obvious Installation in Existing Cutouts – Not Suitable for Large Items – Relatively High Price |
Check Price Amazon.com |
SentrySafe |
– Ideal Closet Size – Fire and Flood Protection – Sturdy Construction – Ample Storage Space – Easy Combination Lock – Bolt-Down Option |
– Humidity Trapping – Plastic Components – Damaged Upon Delivery – Cumbersome Dial Lock – Questionable Customer Support – Non-Changeable Combination |
Check Price Amazon.com |
REVIEWS OF MY BEST JEWELRY SAFES
Amazon Basics
| REASONS TO BUY | REASONS TO AVOID |
|---|---|
| Affordable Price: One of the main advantages of this safe is its budget-friendly price, making it accessible to customers with tight budgets. Adequate Storage Space: Many customers have found the safe to be spacious enough to store important documents, cash, jewelry, and other valuables. Easy-to-Use Keypad: Several reviews mention that the keypad is user-friendly and straightforward to set up, enabling quick access to the safe’s contents. Sturdy Build: Some buyers have praised the safe’s overall sturdiness, providing a sense of security for basic storage needs. Dual Locking Mechanisms: The inclusion of both a keypad and key-based locking system offers users multiple options for accessing the safe, adding flexibility to its use. | Thin Walls and Lightweight Construction: The safe’s thin metal walls and lightweight design may raise concerns about its durability and ability to withstand break-in attempts. Lack of Fireproofing and Waterproofing: Several negative reviews highlight the absence of fireproof and waterproof features, making it unsuitable for protecting valuable items in the event of a disaster. Faulty Keypad and Key Mechanisms: A significant number of customers faced issues with the keypad or key, ranging from intermittent malfunctions to complete failure. Inadequate Mounting Design: Some users found the mounting holes and hardware to be poorly designed, potentially compromising the safe’s security when installed. Moisture Vulnerability: The presence of multiple mounting holes in the back and bottom may allow moisture to penetrate inside, putting valuable contents at risk of humidity and mildew. Limited Customer Support: Some buyers expressed frustration with the lack of responsive customer support, making it difficult to address issues or seek assistance. |
REVIEW
The product in question appears to be a safe with mixed reviews from customers. While some customers have expressed satisfaction with the purchase, citing its reasonable price and adequate space for storing items, many others have highlighted significant issues and concerns.
Several negative reviews point out crucial drawbacks of the safe. The primary complaints include the thin metal walls, lack of fireproofing or waterproofing capabilities, and potential ease of tearing the safe out of the wall due to its lightweight build. Some customers also faced difficulties with the keypad and key mechanisms, with instances of the keypad not working, the key jamming or snapping, and the fingerprint option failing after a short period of use. Such issues significantly compromised the safe’s reliability and security, leaving some customers feeling dissatisfied with their purchase.
The mounting hardware and installation process received criticism as well. Some customers found the mounting holes problematic, allowing moisture to penetrate the safe and potentially damage the valuables inside. Others faced challenges with the mounting screws and anchors, finding them inadequate or difficult to work with.
Additionally, a few customers raised concerns about the lack of fire-retardant properties, suggesting that it may not be the best choice for protecting valuable documents and items from fire damage.
On a more positive note, some customers praised the safe for being spacious and well-built for basic needs. They appreciated its easy-to-use keypad, sturdiness, and reasonable price, considering it a valuable purchase for keeping items secure and away from unwanted access.
In summary, this safe seems to have some issues with its build quality, keypad functionality, and mounting features. While some customers found it suitable for their basic needs and appreciated its affordability, many others were disappointed with its performance, especially considering the lack of fireproofing capabilities. It’s essential for potential buyers to carefully weigh the mixed feedback before making a decision on whether this safe meets their specific requirements and expectations.
KAPUCI
| REASONS TO BUY | REASONS TO AVOID |
|---|---|
| Multiple Access Options: The safe offers various access methods, including a fingerprint scanner and a digital number pad, providing convenient and quick ways to open the safe. Sleek and Modern Design: Customers appreciate the attractive appearance of the safe, with its clean white finish and a luxury look that fits well with modern decor. Internal Padding and Shelf: The fully padded interior, along with a glass shelf, allows for organized storage and protection of valuable items and jewelry. Auto-Open and Auto-Close: The safe’s auto-open and auto-close features ensure that the door is securely locked after use, reducing the risk of leaving it unlocked accidentally. Spacious Interior: Despite its compact size, the safe offers ample space inside, making it suitable for storing various personal belongings. Easy Setup and Installation: Many customers find the setup and installation process straightforward, enabling them to start using the safe quickly. | Poor Fingerprint Lock Recognition: Several users report that the fingerprint scanner’s performance is inconsistent, leading to frustration and concerns about the safe’s security. Build Quality Issues: Some reviewers mention craftsmanship problems, such as unlevel knobs, paint drips, and a fragile glass shelf, suggesting potential durability concerns. Stability Concerns: The safe’s weight and design make it prone to tipping over when opening, necessitating additional anchoring for stability. Limited Security: Certain customers express disappointment with the lack of reliability in the fingerprint reader, as it seems to open with any fingerprint, potentially compromising the safe’s security. Inadequate Customer Support: Dissatisfied customers mention difficulty in reaching responsive customer service when facing issues or needing assistance with their safes. Price vs. Value: Some feel that the product’s price is relatively high compared to similar safes on the market, given the reported drawbacks in its functionality and construction. |
REVIEW
The product in question is a safe with multiple access options, including a fingerprint scanner and a digital number pad. It is described as sturdy and easy to set up, with a sleek and modern design. Some customers appreciate the added security of an Apple AirTag to track the safe in case of theft.
However, several negative points are highlighted across the reviews. The fingerprint lock recognition is criticized as being poor, with some claiming that any fingerprint can open the safe, rendering it less secure than expected. Some also mention that the craftsmanship and build quality are average, with issues like unlevel knobs, paint drips, and a glass shelf that easily shatters.
The safe’s weight and steadiness are also a concern, with one customer mentioning the need to weigh it down to prevent tipping when opening the door. Some reviewers express disappointment with the alarm’s effectiveness, and the battery compartment is stated to be for memory purposes only, not for actually opening the safe.
While some customers praise the product for its quick fingerprint scanner and easy setup, others report issues with the fingerprint reader not working properly, especially when hands are sweaty or moist. Additionally, there are complaints about the customer service not being responsive, leaving some customers frustrated when trying to resolve issues with their safes.
The overall consensus seems to be that the safe has potential, especially with its various access methods and internal padding. However, there are several concerns about its security, build quality, and responsiveness of the fingerprint reader. Some customers feel that it may not provide the level of protection they were hoping for, especially given its higher price compared to similar products. Despite the mixed reviews, some customers are satisfied with their purchase and appreciate the added features and design of the safe.
Paragon
| REASONS TO BUY | REASONS TO AVOID |
|---|---|
| Affordable Price: This wall safe comes at a budget-friendly cost, making it an attractive option for those seeking basic security without breaking the bank. Ease of Installation: Many customers found the installation process straightforward, taking around 20 minutes or less, saving time and effort. Provides Basic Security: For keeping small valuables, personal items, or handguns away from children and casual intruders, this safe may serve its purpose adequately. Hidden Installation Option: Its flush face design allows you to hide the safe discreetly behind a picture or wall hanging, adding an extra layer of security. Sturdy Construction: Despite some quality concerns, a few buyers found the safe to be reasonably well-made and capable of providing a sense of security. | Poor Packaging and Assembly: Many customers received the product with parts scattered and missing, indicating inadequate packaging. The safe’s assembly and alignment also proved problematic, leading to issues with the door and hinges. Subpar Quality: Several users reported a lack of attention to detail in the manufacturing process, resulting in loose hinges, flimsy lock mechanisms, and other functional flaws. Limited Interior Space: The locking mechanism occupies a significant portion of the middle shelf, reducing the available storage space and limiting the usability of the safe. Lack of Instructions and Support: Customers expressed frustration with the absence of clear instructions and inadequate customer support, leaving them to figure out installation and usage on their own. Unreliable Performance: There were complaints about the keypad malfunctioning, batteries draining quickly, and the locking mechanism jamming, raising concerns about the overall reliability and longevity of the product. Not Suitable for High-Security Needs: If you require a safe with advanced features like fireproofing or burglary resistance, this basic model may not meet your security expectations. Questionable Durability: The safe’s construction and materials have raised doubts about its long-term durability and ability to withstand wear and tear. |
REVIEW
Upon receiving the product, many customers had issues with the packaging, with parts scattered and some small pieces missing due to poor handling during shipping. Additionally, the initial inspection revealed crooked attachment of the safe’s door, causing difficulties in closing it properly. Some noticed a slight curve in the door, preventing it from being flush with the frame when closed, potentially compromising security.
Many customers expressed disappointment with the overall quality of the safe, with loose hinges and subpar construction, leading to a general perception that it was poorly assembled and lacked attention to detail. Some even resorted to disassembling and reassembling the safe themselves to make it functional, which should not be necessary for a product claiming to be well-made.
Another major complaint was the lack of clear instructions or installation templates, leaving customers to figure it out on their own. Several customers were frustrated with the locking mechanism taking up too much space on the middle shelf, rendering it almost useless for storing items.
While some reviewers found the safe easy to install, others encountered issues like loud keypads, faulty locking mechanisms, or difficulty in opening the safe after a short period of use. Some noted that the keypad stopped working, leaving them reliant solely on the key.
On the positive side, a few customers appreciated the affordable price and the ease of installation. They found it suitable for their basic needs, such as storing small items and firearms away from curious hands.
Overall, the general consensus among customers was that this wall safe from Paragon was not of the highest quality, with several glaring issues affecting its functionality and reliability. Many customers had reservations about recommending the product to others due to these shortcomings, urging potential buyers to be cautious before making a purchase.
Elder Welder
| REASONS TO BUY | REASONS TO AVOID |
|---|---|
| 1. Inconspicuous Design: The hidden wall safe’s design allows it to seamlessly blend into your home’s interior, disguising itself as an ordinary outlet. This makes it an ideal choice for discreetly storing small valuable items without drawing attention. 2. Easy Installation: Users have reported that the safe is straightforward to install, taking only a short amount of time. With well-written instructions and included templates, even those with limited DIY experience can set it up without hassle. 3. Robust Construction: The safe is constructed from quality materials, featuring thick and durable steel. This provides confidence in the product’s ability to withstand normal wear and tear, adding to its longevity. 4. Secure Lock Mechanism: The safe’s lock and magnetic faceplate work well, providing a level of security for your valuables. It comes with two keys, allowing you easy and secure access to your hidden items. 5. Customizable Cover Plate: The option to change the cover plate design enables you to match the safe with your existing outlets, ensuring a seamless integration into your home’s decor. 6. Excellent Customer Service: Some users have reported positive experiences with the company’s customer service, receiving prompt assistance in case of missing parts or other issues. | 1. Limited Storage Capacity: The safe’s small size might not be suitable for those looking to store larger items or a significant amount of cash. It is more suitable for holding small items like rings, keys, and USB drives. 2. Shallow Depth: The shallow cavity of the safe may limit its usability for bulkier items or those with deeper dimensions. 3. Installation Compatibility Concerns: Some users have expressed concerns about the safe’s compatibility with different wall types and stud cavity depths. Clarification on this aspect from the manufacturer would be beneficial. 4. Potentially Weak Mounting: The included small screws for mounting on drywall have raised concerns for some users, who have questioned the overall strength and integrity of the mounting method. 5. Obvious Installation in Existing Cutouts: If you plan to install the safe in an existing cutout space, be aware that the specific dimensions required might not match standard electrical box cutouts, limiting its installation options. 6. Not Suitable for Large Items: Due to its size, the safe may not be the best choice if you intend to store documents or larger valuables like cash bundles or watches. 7. Relatively High Price: Compared to other traditional safes, the hidden wall safe’s price might be considered high, especially considering its limited storage capacity. |
REVIEW
The hidden wall safe under review has garnered a diverse range of opinions from users. Many users have praised the product for its inconspicuous design, applauding its ability to seamlessly blend into the surroundings and go unnoticed. They find it easy to install and appreciate the option to change the cover plate to match existing outlets in their homes. The product’s robust construction, magnetic faceplate, and secure lock mechanism have also received positive remarks, making it an attractive choice for storing small valuable items like rings, watches, keys, and USB drives.
However, some users have expressed concerns about the safe’s limited capacity and shallow depth, making it unsuitable for storing larger items or a significant amount of cash. Others found the screws provided for installation to be small and less secure, leading them to devise alternative methods to fix the safe to the wall. Some even suggested the use of stronger adhesive like Gorilla glue for added security.
The product’s compatibility with various wall types and cavity depths has been a subject of contention, with conflicting reports from users about its usability with different drywall thicknesses and stud cavity depths. There have been calls for the manufacturer to provide clearer instructions regarding the product’s installation on different wall types.
While many have commended the company’s excellent customer service, quick response to missing parts, and willingness to replace faulty units, a few users have also expressed dissatisfaction with the customer service or the initial condition of the product they received.
Overall, the hidden wall safe appears to be a reliable option for discreetly safeguarding small valuable items. Its sturdy construction, magnetic faceplate, and lock mechanism inspire confidence in its security features. However, potential buyers should consider its limited storage capacity and ensure compatibility with their wall type before making a purchase. The product’s appeal lies in its ability to deceive potential thieves, with the guise of an ordinary outlet making it less susceptible to theft, especially when installed in inconspicuous locations.
SentrySafe
| REASONS TO BUY | REASONS TO AVOID |
|---|---|
| Ideal Closet Size: The safe’s perfect size for fitting inside a closet makes it a convenient choice for discreet storage and easy access to important documents and valuables. Fire and Flood Protection: With its fireproof and waterproof features, this safe provides added peace of mind for safeguarding critical items in case of emergencies. Sturdy Construction: Many customers appreciate the solid build quality, as the safe is heavy and well-constructed, deterring potential thieves. Ample Storage Space: The safe offers sufficient room for organizing and securing various valuables, including documents, cash, precious metals, and handguns. Easy Combination Lock: For those who prefer traditional security methods, the combination lock offers a simple and reliable way to access the safe. Bolt-Down Option: The safe can be bolted to the floor or wall, providing an extra layer of security against theft. | Humidity Trapping: Some users reported issues with trapped humidity inside the safe, necessitating the use of desiccants to mitigate potential damage to sensitive items. Plastic Components: The plastic door handle and combination dial raise concerns about their durability and security, potentially compromising the safe’s integrity against break-in attempts. Damaged Upon Delivery: Several customers received the product with scratches, dents, or damages, likely caused during shipping, which may impact its overall performance and appearance. Cumbersome Dial Lock: Some find the dial lock cumbersome to use, with concerns about its smoothness and occasional sticking, leading to a desire for a more user-friendly touchpad option. Questionable Customer Support: A few reviewers mentioned difficulties in reaching customer service for assistance with lock malfunctions or other issues, causing frustration in resolving problems. Non-Changeable Combination: There are concerns that the factory-set combination might limit customization options, requiring the purchase of a different model with a key to set a personal combination. |
REVIEW
The safe in question appears to have a perfect size for fitting inside a closet, making it a suitable option for safeguarding documents from floods and fire. However, several customers have noticed that the safe tends to trap humidity inside, leading to the recommendation of using desiccants to mitigate this issue. While the safe is fireproof and waterproof, some users expressed dissatisfaction with the plastic door handle, raising concerns about its durability during potential break-in attempts.
The combination lock seems to be a point of contention for some buyers, as they wish it were made of metal instead of plastic. Some are uncertain if it is possible to set a custom combination, suggesting that opting for the version with a key might be necessary to achieve this functionality.
In terms of build quality, opinions are mixed. While some customers find the safe to be well-constructed and sturdy, others have concerns about its durability, with mentions of dents and damages upon delivery. The plastic dial used in the combination mechanism receives criticism for being flimsy and inconvenient, leading some to regret not choosing a model with a touchpad instead.
Despite these concerns, many customers are content with the safe’s size and functionality, finding it suitable for their needs and appreciating the fireproof and waterproof features. The heavy and solid construction also adds to its appeal for home use. However, others have reported issues with the combination mechanism, with some finding it difficult to set or experiencing malfunctions that required assistance from customer service.
The safe’s security features also come under scrutiny, with some questioning the integrity of the product due to damages sustained during shipping. Furthermore, there are doubts about the security of the combination dial, with concerns that it may be vulnerable to manipulation.
On the positive side, the safe’s fireproof and waterproof qualities receive praise, and its weight and sturdy build provide reassurance against theft. However, the plastic components, including the handle and combination dial, receive mixed reviews, with doubts about their durability in extreme situations, such as fires.
In summary, the safe appears to have its strengths in terms of size, fireproof, and waterproof capabilities. However, there are concerns about its build quality, particularly related to the plastic components. The combination lock system also elicits mixed opinions, with some finding it cumbersome and potentially less secure. Overall, while the safe seems to fulfill its basic purpose, there are aspects that could be improved to enhance its overall value and customer satisfaction.
